i am telling this story because i don't really understand what happened, and i think maybe if i write it out i will be able to make sense out of all the little details.
on my refrigerator is a picture taken early last semester. in the picture, i am sitting on the lap of mike the tiger, flanked on either side by chancellor mark emmert and his wife delaine. i am wearing pink and smiling a huge cheesy smile.
people always think this picture is strange and funny. sometimes they think the man and woman in the picture are my parents; i've overheard someone say, "man, ann's parents are really weird-looking." sometimes they think the man and woman are cardboard cut-outs of the chancellor and his wife--and let's be honest, they might as well be. sometimes they ask me if i'm smiling for serious. but wouldn't you smile ridiculously big if you were taking a picture on your college mascot's knee?
jordan, a boy from monroe whom breton met last summer in canada, stayed with us this week for spring testing. he saw that picture on the fridge. and he told me last night that he thought that picture was hilarious. "because," he said, "you look so innocent. but really you're a vixen."
a vixen? moi?
well, good goddamn, apparently so.
last friday, ben asked me to go to goodwill with him to buy green stuff for becca and elizabeth's green party. it was kind of out-of-the-blue. ben and i are cool, but we've never hung out one on one before. and i almost turned him down. i don't know why; i guess it's one of my anti-social hang-ups. i don't know ben that well, and i didn't know if it would be awkward, and it takes so much energy to sustain a conversation--especially an awkward one with someone you don't know very well--but for some reason i said yes. and we went to a few thrift stores, and then we went to dinner together afterwards, and it was really nice. and a lot less weird than i thought it would be.
over the course of the afternoon, i mentioned the cameron situation to ben, and told him that i wondered if cameron had been hitting on me. and ben said, "maybe he's just being friendly." and that gave me pause. i don't know, lately i've started to wonder if any completely, totally, utterly platonic relationship can exist between the sexes. it seems as though one of the two parties involved will inevitably, at some point, want something more. and with guys--i don't know. it takes so much effort to strike up a new relationship--and i mean "relationship" in the "sustained interaction with another human" sense of the word. and--well, as barrett put it today at lunch, "men are about agency; women are about community." that may be a lot of biological predetermination bullshit, but. i don't know many guys who would put forth a lot of energy into a relationship that they didn't think had the potential to turn romantic (or, more accurately, sexual).
my point being, ben asking me to go to goodwill, and then getting dinner--i was kinda suspicious--not paranoid, but curious--as to why. was he just being friendly? and when he suggested that cameron was "just being friendly," i concluded that ben must be one of those rare guys who does put effort into simple friendships.
at dinner, i can't remember how it started, but i told him my theory that i could probaby make out with a girl but i couldn't ever have sex with one. and ben has had girlfriends, but, as i understand it, lately he's been experimenting. and so when i said that i could make out with a girl but not have sex with one, he said, "you know, that's what i've come to discover about myself and guys." and he went on to explain how girls are much nicer to kiss.
anyway, thursday night i went out with breton and jordan and ben and becca to the spanish moon for '80s night. i'd never been to '80s night before; i didn't really have any interest in going to '80's night; however, breton needed to go out, and she asked me to go, and so i went. i thought it was going to be lame. i was sorely mistaken. i think that was probably the most fun i've ever had at a bar. it had little to do with '80s night. it had everything to do with my friends, who are fucking incredible. we all danced, the whole time. there was none of that awkward high school bullshit about dancing in a little circle and wishing someone would dance with you. i danced with breton, i danced with becca, i danced with jordan, i danced with tom and laren (we found them there)--i didn't really know what to do with ben. jordan and tom are gay, so the whole flirtation thing was moot. but with ben--i didn't know how he would take it. so i very deliberately didn't make any kind of advances towards him. but he made a move towards me. so then i danced with him, but kept a respectable distance between us. and he closed the gap. anyway, we danced a lot, and got all sweaty, and it was ridiculous and wonderful.
the situation is entirely too complicated to explain here, but suffice it to say that i wasn't sure how kosher it was for me to be doing anything that could be construed as flirting with ben. but by the time the bar closed, it was pretty clear that there was at least a little something going on. to further complicate things, jordan told breton he thought ben was hot; apparently ben told becca he thought jordan was hot; becca and breton decided they would try to hook the two guys up. so breton tells me this, and i'm thinking, "hmmm...what's really going on here?" i thought maybe ben was outwardly flirting with me but inwardly he wanted jordan.
so we decide to go to louie's. and becca's driving, and breton's riding shotgun, and i'm sitting between jordan and ben in the back. it was ben's birthday, and he was wearing a button-down shirt and a tie. and he kept swatting at me with his tie. mind you, he was sober. we were both sober, which only makes the fact that i had fun dancing at a bar more incredible. and he was swatting at me with his tie. and then he took the end of his tie and tied it around my wrist. these are silly things a drunk person might do. but he was not drunk. he was sober. and i was even more confused.
after louie's, i drove me and breton and jordan home--and we dropped ben off on the way. and so we said goodnight, and from the driver's seat i gave him my hand like i expected him to shake it--and he looked at me and shook his head and leaned in to give me a hug.
the next day i told him i'd go with him to see "accidental death of an anarchist"--breton had work, but jordan said he wanted to come. and breton repeated her desire to get the two boys to hook up. and i am totally confused. we meet ben at the show, and at intermission he asks us if we want to go dancing that night. and i'm thinking "geez, we just went dancing last night" and i tell him that actually, i was gonna go drink at chelsea's. after the show was over, i asked him what his plans were, and he said that maybe he would just go home. and i said that he should come to chelsea's. and he said ok.
so jordan and i go home, and i feed the cat, and i call barrett and tell him to come out with us, and eventually we wind up at chelsea's. cameron is there with some german exchange kids. and barrett shows up kinda drunk already. and then ben shows up. and anna is there, and he goes over and talks to her for a while, and jordan joins him. and me and barrett hang out with cameron and the german kids. there was a terrible band playing--bandname: Ballzack--i'm sure you can imagine the horror. it was like crappy Beastie Boys. eventually the german kids leave, and anna leaves, and it's me, cameron, barrett, ben, jordan, and ben's friend reese. and cameron and ben decide that a good thing to do would be to buy some beer and whiskey and go someplace else to continue drinking.
at this point, i have had one and a half jack and cokes. i am drunk. i am sitting next to cameron, and i tell him, "i am drunk." and he says, "really??" and i say, "what, aren't you?" and he says "no, no."
so we pile into jordan's jeep--me and ben and jordan and cameron. and reese and barrett follow us to ben's house. there is a piano at ben's house, and so i play piano drunkenly while ben and cameron go out in search of alcohol. finally they come back with beer and jack, and ben fixes me another jack and coke, and everyone else takes shots, and we attempt to play some stupid drinking game with cards but we fail miserably. and barrett is wasted at this point, and i am too. i say "i am drunk," and cameron says, "really??" and i say, "what, aren't you?" and he says "no, no."
then he accidentally kicks over my drink. we were sitting on the sofa--barrett, me, cameron--and i had put my drink on the floor, and it was mostly full, and cameron kicked it over. and ben grabs some towels and wipes it up, and i grab a fallen ice cube and drop it down cameron's shirt, because i am in fact twelve years old. so he does me one better: he grabs another ice cube and drops it down my underwear. i was wearing a skirt, and he dropped it down the waist in the back. and then he held it in place. so basically he's grabbing my ass, and there's ice, and it's very cold.
at some point i get up from the sofa, and when i return, ben has taken my seat between barrett and cameron. and ben and cameron tell me to just sit down on top of them, and so i do. i'm slouched down, halfway on ben's lap and halfway on cameron's. and i say: i am drunk. cameron says, "really??" because of course, he's not drunk.
ben goes to take a sip of beer and he somehow misses his mouth and spills beer on my stomach. and it is very cold and i start laughing because it was cold and i was drunk and he spilled beer on my stomach and it was cold. and while i am laughing, he straight up pours the rest of the beer on me. on my stomach. pours it. and i am dying laughing. then he apologizes and gets me a t-shirt to change into.
so i change into the t-shirt and when i come back, ben is sprawled out on the other sofa, surrounded by pillows like a little cocoon. and i tell him that his pillow nest looks very comfortable, and he tells me to come sit by him, and so i sprawl out on top of him, and then cameron comes and sprawls on me, and then barrett comes and leaps on top. and it was painful. and then we de-pile. cameron stands up and wanders around the room for about ten minutes, looking really lost and confused. i am a little concerned. then he sits down and promptly falls asleep. passes out. because he was stone-cold sober.
i am still laying next to/on top of ben on the sofa. and barrett is talking excitedly to reese about god knows what. and cameron is out. and jordan is looking a little forlorn. and ben whispers to me, "you should stay a little longer." and i am so confused. and jordan is drunk. and ben whispers, "we need to get jordan to take a nap." and jordan won't. ben gets up for a minute and jordan tells me that he really wants to hook up with ben, and do i think he has a chance? and i'm like "ummmmm...ummmmm...i dunno...."
at this point i'm sobering up and i decide i will bring jordan home and then come back to hang out with ben. and i stand up, announce my intention to drive home, and ben is sitting on the sofa, and i lean in to tell him that i'll be back, and he kisses me. jordan is sitting right there. and ben kisses me, and i can't even move. and finally i straighten up, and ben leaves the room for a minute, and i sit down and jordan's like, "did he just kiss you?" and i'm like "ummm.........i dunno......" and he's like "you don't know? if he kissed you?" and i'm like "i guess he did...." and jordan is sad because he wanted to hook up with ben, but he says that it seems like ben wants me more than him, and that's ok. and i apologize, and tell him that i don't actually have any earthly idea what's going on. and he says it's cool.
anyway, i brought him home and took my car back to ben's house. and cameron was still passed out on the sofa. ben was fiddling with the stereo. and then there was a lot of really excellent kissing. really, really, really. he tells me that he had wanted to kiss me thursday when we went out dancing, but he thought maybe i was just teasing him, and he was afraid i would have gotten freaked out. and he tells me he can't believe that i am kissing him after he poured beer on me. and i laugh and say that i can't believe he missed his mouth and spilled it on me in the first place, and he says, "um...it was a little more deliberate than that." and i say, "what, you did it on purpose?" and he says, "well........yeah."
the sun came up and he fell asleep and of course i didn't, because i never do. i lay there with him for a while, and at 6:30 i got up out of bed. and i was gathering my stuff and he pulled me back into bed by the back waist of my pajama pants. and he kissed me and told me, "you should stay here. all the time." and i laughed and said, "all the time?" and he said, "yeah. what do you think about that?" and i said, "but ben, i have to go to sleep eventually." then i kissed him and told him goodnight.
let me take this opportunity to say how amazed i am by boys right now--particularly by boys whom i know to be painfully shy. ben included. i don't know how these guys manage to be effectively aggressive with girls. i am not painfully shy and there is no way i could ever make anything that could be clearly construed as a move. playful flirting i can handle; veiled references as to my actual feelings are harder but manageable; straightforward aggression i couldn't pull off if my life depended on it. i stand in gratitude and admiration for these boys. i'm so glad they exist. otherwise i would be doomed to lead a sad and lonely life plagued by my own chickenshit unrequited love.
anyway. we talked a little bit between kisses, but i left with a lot of unanswered questions. for example: why me? and how long has this been going on? and what does this all mean, anyway? and don't you like guys? i didn't ask him any of these questions because i didn't want to freak him out; i was enjoying whatever we had going that night and didn't want to spoil it. if it was a one time thing, that's fine. if not, it's going to require a lot of explanation as to what i can and can't handle as far as relationship stuff goes right now. which is such a pain in the ass.
also at this point i wasn't even sure if i had fucked up horribly, because i had reason to believe ben was off-limits for me. i wrote a note to breton when i got home; it said "oh breton. i need to talk to you." so she woke me up when she saw the note, and i told her what happened and she got all excited and said it was very cute. and i asked her if she thought it was kosher, all things considered, and she said yes definitely. and i felt better.
so i keep stopping and standing and thinking about it--i can't stop thinking about it--i think about it and it makes me a little bit breathless.